The FSBO Fallacy: Why Selling Your Own Home Won’t Save On Commissions

Dated: February 10 2019

Views: 107

Although some people are very successful at selling their own home, the process can be a literal minefield. Not only can it be very time-consuming, there are many mistakes unrepresented sellers (FSBO’s) can make, some of which can cost more than the commission FSBO’s may think they’re saving by not listing with a Realtor. 

recent study by Collateral Analytics (CA) shows that unrepresented sellers not only do not save money on commissions, in some cases they may actually net substantially less than what they would have had they listed with a full service, licensed real estate agent.  In the study, CA analyzed home sales statistics in a variety of U.S. real estate markets in both 2016 and in the first half of 2017. The data revealed several key findings:

“FSBOs tend to sell for lower prices than comparable home sales, and in many cases below the average differential represented by the prevailing commission rate.”


Why would a FSBO net less money than if they used a Realtor? 


The CA study suggests that there are several possible explanations:

Bargain Hunters: FSBO listings might be attracting more strategic buyers or “bargain hunters” than MLS listings do. The idea is that prospective buyers may be rationalizing their lower-priced bids on FSBOs on the basis that FSBO sellers are “saving” roughly 6% on real estate commissions. If bargain hunters are routinely searching for and targeting unrepresented sellers, this could explain why FSBOs systematically garner lower bids on their homes, thus causing FSBOs to net lower sales prices.

Mediocre Staging: Unlike FSBO sellers, experienced agents understand what it takes to make a listing shine online and in person. A full service Realtor knows that, often, this look can only achieved with the assistance of a professional stager. A seller who lists their home with a Realtor may net more money for their home as a result of the extensive preparation and professional staging their home may undergo prior to listing.

Inadequate Exposure: When a FSBO is listed for sale, the ability of the seller to comprehensively market that property both on and offline may be seriously limited for a variety of reasons: a FSBO may lack time, marketing expertise, access to distribution channels and more. Most FSBOs do not even know to ask for showing feedback so they're not in a good position to adjust to market input.  On the other hand, properties listed with a Realtor who is a member of the local Multiple Listing Service (MLS) are often better prepared to meet buyers' expectations and are simultaneously syndicated online to all MLS participating members’ websites, thus marketing the home to the largest possible buyer population. And those MLS member listings generally offer compensation to agents who represent buyers, incentivizing agents to show and sell the property, thus potentially enlarging the buyer pool. If more traffic can be generated for a given home, there is a greater likelihood that the property will garner multiple bids, increasing the chance of driving up the final sales price.

Three Key Conclusions were three key conclusions generated from the CA study:

  1. FSBOs achieve significantly lower sales prices than similar properties sold by licensed Realtors utilizing the MLS.
  2. 2.   FSBOs tend to net sales prices that are, on average, 5.5% less compared to similar properties marketed on the MLS.
  3. 2017 sales suggested the average sales price of a FSBO was close to 6% lower than the sales price of similar MLS-listed properties.


If you’re thinking of selling your home on your own to save on commissions, it may end up costing you more money than you would have saved had you listed with a real estate agent. 

Here is my Pledge of Performance and the many Seller Services I have to offer…  Working together, I’ll get your home sold FAST for top dollar!

Blog author image

Michelle Meenach

Cincinnati’s Top 3% | Sr Sales Vice President | selling Fast for Top Dollar | from Neighborhood to Luxury, I'll help you find the Home you Love As your Realtor, I bring a breadth of experience and ....

Latest Blog Posts

Median Sold Price Increase Puts Pressure on Housing Affordability

Interest rates continue to remain around 3%, according to the National Association of REALTORS® (NAR). Condo prices lead the way with prices up 18% from the same time last year,

Read More


Moving presents a host of choices. For example, in the course of preparing for the transition, you will need to determine which real estate agent to hire, which house to buy, and what items you

Read More

What to Know About Today's Busy Market

You’re probably well aware that the real estate market is more competitive than ever (due to low inventory, among other things).Still, it’s not a bad time to buy a house. Mortgage rates

Read More

Why Agents Who Cut Commission Could Cost You MORE!

6 Reasons Why Real Estate Agents May Reduce Their Commission, and Why It Could Cost You Plenty1.  They need the business. In today's competitive market some agents are offering to cut their

Read More